Survivor 30: Anyone Else Sick of the No Collar Tribe?

So, I just watched the third episode of Survivor 30 and I’m just wondering:

Am I the only one who is sick to death of the No Collar Tribe?

Seriously, what a bunch of hypocrites!  Hali and Jenn might spend a lot of time talking about how they’re nonjudgmental free spirits but, so far this season, they have proven themselves to be the mean girls of Survivor.  Will seems like a nice guy but he’s pretty much useless in challenges and I don’t know how much more I can take of having to listen to him go, “That one is on me, guys.”  I liked Joe at first but, as far as strategy goes, he tends to overthink and he’s nowhere close to being as clever as he thinks he is.

Don’t get me wrong.  I agree with the choice that the No Collar Tribe made tonight.  By a vote of 3-2, Nina was voted out of the tribe.  I could make a case that Will should have been voted out but, ultimately, Nina needed to go.  Along with being weak in challenges, she was also proving to be a divisive presence in the camp.  I felt bad for her because I know that she felt like an outsider from the beginning and, judging from her comments after being voted out, Nina probably feels that her deafness was the only reason she was voted out.  But, honestly, Nina was mostly voted out because of her attitude and her age.  She never had a chance of surviving on that tribe and I doubt any of the other tribes would have kept her either.

As for the other two tribes, we didn’t see much of the White Collar Tribe.  Shirin is getting on everyone’s nerves and her delight over seeing monkeys having sex leads me to suspect that perhaps she should have been placed on the No Collar Tribe.  Joaquin needs to work on his social skills but I do think that an alliance between he and Tyler could be a strong one.

Speaking of Tyler, I have a feeling he’s going to be sticking around for a while.  Despite the fact that there hasn’t been much going on over on the White Collar Tribe, he’s still been getting a lot of screen time.

Meanwhile, on the Blue Collar Tribe — what a bunch of entitled babies!  The only thing that’s keeping me from going off on the Blue Collar Tribe is the fact that I somehow dislike the No Collar Tribe even more.  Rodney and Lindsay both spent tonight acting like entitled babies.  Mike was making some valid points tonight but he needs to work on his social skills.  Meanwhile, Dan … well, Dan’s Dan.  So far, the Blue Collar Tribe has been the only tribe not to have to go to tribal council.  When they finally do lose an immunity challenge, it should be explosive.

Next week, we’ve got a special two hour episode of Survivor!  It’ll be interesting to see if No Collar can get its act together.  Even more importantly, we’ll see how much longer this show continues with three tribes.  I suspect that a tribal shake-up is coming.

We’ll find out next week!

Lisa Marie

Survior 30: The No Collar Tribe Gets Flakey

Well, that was a surprise.

Seriously, I just got finished watching the second episode of Survivor 30 (or Survivor: Worlds Apart for those of you who think you’re too good for numbers) and I have to say that I was surprised how things turned out.

First off, I was expecting that the White Collar Tribe would be the ones sent to tribal council.  During the previous episode, they gave off the vibe of the doomed and I fully expected that this would turn out to be yet another season of Survivor where one tribe lost challenge after challenge until, finally, the two remaining members would mercifully be placed in one of the other two tribes.  I fully expected that White Collar would lose again and Joaquin would be voted out.

Instead, White Collar not only won immunity but it was largely Joaquin who won it for them.  I still think that Joaquin may have come on a little bit too strong during the previous episode but, if he can lay low and win back everyone’s trust, he could still be a very strong player.

White Collar came in first in the immunity competition and, along with immunity, they won a lot of fishing gear.  (Which is something that they’ll need, seeing as how Joaquin chose the small bag of beans during the previous episode.)  Blue Collar came in second and won a spear.  No Collar came in dead last and won a trip to tribal council.

I forget what the official name of the No Collar Tribe is but, from now on, I think I’ll just refer to them as being the Flakey Tribe.  Because, seriously, these people couldn’t come up with a consistent strategy if their lives depended upon it.

Tonight’s episode was pretty much dominated by the Flakey Tribe’s dynamic.  For all of the time that they spend bragging about how open-minded they are, Jenn and Hali are pretty much this season’s mean girls.  While they spent most of their time skinny dipping and laying around on the beach with Joe, they also managed to totally alienate Nina.  Not only is Nina older than them but she’s also deaf.  She’s an outsider and, this episode, she let everyone know that she realizes she’s an outsider and she’s not very happy about it.

For most of tonight’s episode, Nina had an outsider’s alliance with Wil and creepy old Vince.   And it looked like they were going to be able to pull off an upset and manage to get Jenn voted out of the tribe.

See, Joe came up with a needlessly complicated plan to get ride of Nina.  His plan was that he, Jenn, Hali, and Will would split their votes between Nina and Vince, just in case one of them had an immunity idol.

However, what Joe didn’t realize was that Wil wasn’t really comfortable being a member of his alliance.  Wil went to Vince and told him about Joe’s plan.  Vince decided that he, Wil, and Nina would vote for Jenn and, as a result, Jenn would be blindsided and Joe would frightened into being loyal to Vince and Nina.

And Vince nearly pulled it off.  The only problem was that Nina told Wil that Vince had earlier thought about voting Wil out, on account of Wil not being a strong challenge player.  Wil was so angry that Vince would even consider voting for him that he basically went rogue and, apparently without letting anyone else in on his plans, he voted for Vince.  The end result was that Vince received 3 votes, Jenn received two, and Nina got one.  Vince’s torch was snuffed and the creepy coconut vendor was sent on his way.

As for the other two tribes, we spent some time watching the White Collar Tribe’s Max and Shirin wander around naked while Tyler stared up at the sky.  And, on the Blue Collar Tribe — well, Dan is still annoying.  He lost his underwear in the ocean and responded by making himself a big diaper that he’ll apparently wear during challenges.

And, uhmmm, yeah.

At this point, Dan cannot be voted out soon enough as far as I’m concerned.

And that was this week’s episode of Survivor!  Though it’s early yet, so far this looks like this could be a pretty good season.  Though I have to admit, I will be happy when the tribes get shaken up and people stop saying stuff like, “Since we’re the no collar tribe…”

Lisa Marie

Survivor 30: Are You Blue Collar, White Collar, Or No Collar?

Hello and welcome to yet another season of Survivor here at the Survivor Blog!

Considering the fact that the last season was something of a disappointment, I know that I’m hoping that Survivor 30: Worlds Apart will provide the show with so much needed redemption. The good news is that this latest season was, once again, filmed on the beautiful beaches and in the jungles of Nicaragua. The even better news is that we finally have a season with no returning players and no relatives.

Instead, we have 18 new players who, until they got dropped off in Nicaragua, were complete strangers to each other.

Still, it wouldn’t be Survivor if there wasn’t a gimmick. This season, we’re starting out with three separate tribes. The Masaya Tribe is white collar. It’s made up of 6 people who, we’re told, are used to “making the rules” and telling other people what to do. The Escemera Tribe is blue collar. They’re the workers. And then there’s the Nagarote Tribe. Nagarote is no collar. Apparently, they neither follow rules nor work. They just exist and do what they want.

Now, here’s the thing. Every season of Survivor has a gimmick and that gimmick usually stops being relevant after the first four episodes. Eventually, the three tribes will be reshuffled into two. And then the two will merge into one. The whole collar thing will eventually be abandoned and it will all come down to who plays the best game or who gets lucky.

But, you wouldn’t necessarily know that from watching the first episode of Season 30. If you took a drink every time somebody specifically said, “I’m blue collar” or “we’re white collar,” you would have been drunk before the show was even half over.

As I watched the show, I found myself wondering which tribe I would have been placed on. On the one hand, I work in an office and I like spending money so that’s a case for white collar. On the other hand, I’m also a writer and I majored in Art History. Ultimately, I have a feeling that I’d be put on the No Collar Tribe. And that’s okay because then I could hang out with Joe.

The majority of tonight’s episode was devoted to getting to know the players. Some of them made a bigger impression than others. Here’s a quick rundown:

The Masaya (White Collar) Tribe:

So — So had the misfortune to be the first person voted out this season. I liked So and I think that Masaya made a mistake getting rid of her. But really, So was her own worst enemy. If she and Joaquin hadn’t lied about the bag of rice, she probably would have survived.

Joaquin — So far, Joaquin seems to be trying way too hard to be this season’s master villain. Considering that his only ally got voted out, Joaquin’s days seem to be numbered.

Max — At one point, Max is described as being a “hipster academic type,” and that’s going to be his downfall. He obviously thinks that he’s very smart but I don’t think he’s as smart as he thinks he is.

Tyler — Tyler is both a former football player and a former talent agent. Tyler seems likable enough but I think his survival will depend on whether or not his tribe continues to implode.

Shirin — Shirin is an executive at Yahoo. She was responsible for the White Collar Tribe losing the immunity challenge and going to Tribal Council. I’ll be shocked if Shirin makes it to the merge.

Carolyn — And then there’s Carolyn, who is almost as annoying as the infamous Kaos Kass. Sadly, Carolyn has an immunity idol but, after just three days on the beach, she’s already way too paranoid for her own good.

The Escamera (Blue Collar) Tribe

Lindsey — Lindsey seems like a strong player. Though we won’t know for sure until they go to their first tribal, I could definitely see Lindsey emerging as the leader of the tribe.

Dan — Dan is a former postal worker. Dan likes to talk and talk and talk and talk. Dan thinks he’s a leader but he’s so full of himself that he’s getting on everyone’s nerves. Dan won’t make the merge.

Mike — I actually like Mike and I hope his early friendship with Dan doesn’t backfire on him. On the one hand, it’s easy to laugh at Mike because he’s the guy who ate a scorpion for no good reason. On the other hand, Mike was also responsible for Escamera coming from behind to win immunity.

Rodney — Rodney sounds like Boston Rob but I think that’s all they have in common.

Kelly — Beyond the fact that she dislike Dan, Kelly didn’t make much of an impression on me.

Sierra — Seirra is another one who didn’t get a whole lot of screen time. She’s incorrectly convinced that Dan and Mike came back with a small bag of beans so that they could go look for an immunity idol, which would seem to suggest that Sierra is too paranoid for her own good.

The Nagarote Tribe (No Collar):

Joe — Joe is currently my favorite player. Not only is he hot but he seems to be smart as well. In fact, Joe reminded me a lot of Malcolm. Assuming Joe doesn’t screw up in some massive way, he definitely seems like he could go far in the game.

Jenn — I think Jenn and Joe would make a cute couple. But Jenn also seems like the type of player who will try to make a big move at the wrong time and end up getting voted out as a result.

Hali — Hali’s a law student but she wants us to know that she’s “for the people.” Bleh. Leave your politics at home and the play the game, Hali.

Nina — Nina is deaf and, judging from the previews of next week’s episode, it appears that Nina feels that she’s an outsider on the tribe.

Will — Will lists his career as being a “youtube sensation.” It took me a few minutes and then I remembered that I had seen Will’s video. It was cute. Otherwise, Will didn’t make much of an impression.

Vince — OH MY GOD, WHAT A CREEP! So, Vince is a coconut salesman. After knowing her for less than a day, Vince is apparently convinced that Jenn is his soulmate and he’s very jealous Joe. The scene where he asked Jenn to hug him was full of all sorts of ick.

As for the show itself, Masaya was the first tribe to go to tribal council and, on a vote of 4-2, So was voted off. With the exception of Joaquin, the rest of the tribe felt that they could not trust So and, as such, they decided to vote her out and keep the physically weaker Carolyn.

As well, Carolyn has the tribe’s secret immunity idol. (The other two tribes have idols hidden on their beaches as well but no one has yet to find either one of them.)

As for the Blue Collar Tribe, Dan is getting on everyone’s nerves and the tribe is now split 4-2, with Dan and Mike on one side and the rest of the tribe on the other.

And, on the No Collar Tribe, Vince is being obsessive and creepy.

Well, that was the first episode of Survivor 30. What did everyone else think? Which tribe would you be put on? And are you looking forward to the rest of the season?

I know I am!

Lisa Marie